A gift agreement or a lifetime care agreement: which is safer and what should you choose?
When we want to secure our old age while also resolving the issue of property, a common dilemma arises: should we enter into a gift agreement with a family member who will take care of us, or a lifetime care agreement?
This decision has long-term legal and family consequences, which is why it is important to understand the difference between these two types of agreements, their advantages and disadvantages, as well as the situations in which one option may be safer than the other.
Below, we explain in detail everything you need to know.
What is a gift agreement?
A gift agreement is a legal transaction in which one person (the donor) transfers property to another person (the recipient) without compensation.
It is most commonly used when parents want to transfer an apartment, house, or other property to their child or another close relative during their lifetime.
It is important to know that when it comes to real estate, a gift agreement must be concluded in written form and notarized.
What does a gift agreement mean in practice?
A gift agreement means that you transfer your property (an apartment, house, or land) to another person without compensation, most often to a child or a close relative.
In practice, it often looks like this:
Parents want to transfer their apartment to their son who already lives with them and takes care of them. They believe it is natural for the property to belong to him, so they decide to conclude a gift agreement.
At the moment the agreement is notarized and registered in the land registry, the son becomes the owner of the apartment.
The parents may agree on a lifetime right of use (usufruct), which means they can continue living in the apartment. However, ownership is permanently transferred.
Advantages of a Gift Agreement
- Simple and quick procedure
- Lower costs compared to some other legal transactions
- Avoids probate proceedings for that property
- Possibility of retaining the right of usufruct - the donor can agree to keep the right to use the apartment or house for life
Disadvantages of a Gift Agreement
- The property immediately transfers to the ownership of the recipient
- There is no obligation of care or support unless it is specifically agreed
- Risk of changes in the recipient’s behavior
The biggest risk of a gift agreement is that the person giving the property is no longer its owner. If family disagreements arise, the recipient gets divorced, or financial problems occur, the donor may lose their sense of security.
In such situations, the donor is no longer the owner, and their legal protection is limited.
What is a lifetime care agreement?
A lifetime care agreement is a contract in which one person (the provider of care) undertakes to care for another person (the recipient of care) for the rest of their life. In return, the provider gains the right to the recipient’s property, but only after the recipient’s death.
This agreement must be made in written form and notarized, with the notary specifically informing the parties about the legal consequences of the contract.
What does a lifetime care agreement involve?
Under a lifetime care agreement, one person undertakes to care for another person until the end of their life, providing housing, food, medical care, assistance, and other necessary support.
In return, the property transfers to the care provider, but only after the death of the care recipient.
In practice, it often looks like this:
An elderly person has no children, but their nephew takes care of them. They conclude a lifetime care agreement. The nephew has a legal obligation to care for them, and the apartment will become his only after their death. Until then, the elderly person remains the owner.
Advantages of a Lifetime Care Agreement
- Greater security for the care recipient
- The property transfers to the care provider only after the recipient’s death
- There is a clear legal obligation of care and support
- If the obligations are not fulfilled, the agreement can be terminated through court
This agreement provides greater legal protection, because the obligation of care is not merely assumed but clearly defined.
Disadvantages of a Lifetime Care Agreement
- A more complex procedure
- Possible legal disputes if disagreements arise
- It may cause dissatisfaction among other heirs
- It requires the real and continuous fulfillment of obligations
It is important to note that property covered by a lifetime care agreement does not become part of the estate and is not divided among heirs.
| Gift Agreement | Lifetime Care Agreement |
|---|---|
| The property immediately transfers into ownership. | The property transfers into ownership only after the death of the care recipient. |
| There is no mandatory obligation of care. | There is a legal obligation of care. |
| More difficult to terminate | Can be terminated due to failure to fulfill obligations. |
| Less legal protection for the donor. | Greater legal security. |
The most important difference is the moment when ownership is transferred and whether there is an obligation of care and support.
When is it better to choose a gift agreement?
A gift agreement can be a good option when:
- There is complete trust between the parties
- There is no need to formally establish an obligation of care
- You want property relations to be resolved in a simple way
- The donor retains the right of lifetime use of the property
For example, if a child is already taking care of a parent and the goal is simply to formally regulate the ownership of the property without additional obligations, a gift agreement may be an appropriate solution.
However, in such cases it is recommended to agree on a right of usufruct, so that the donor retains the security of living in the property.
When is it safer to conclude a lifetime care agreement?
A lifetime care agreement is a safer option when:
- An elderly person depends on someone else’s care
- They want a legally binding guarantee of support
- There is a risk of future family disputes
- They want to retain full control over their property until death
This agreement is especially recommended when the property has significant value or when there are multiple potential heirs, as it clearly defines the rights and obligations of the parties.
What is legally safer?
From the perspective of protecting the elderly person, a lifetime care agreement is generally safer.
Reasons:
- Ownership is not transferred immediately
- There is a legal obligation of care and support
- The agreement can be terminated if obligations are not fulfilled
- It provides greater protection against potential abuse
In the case of a gift agreement, protection depends entirely on the mutual trust between the parties.
Most common mistake
- Signing a contract without legal advice
- Poorly defined care and support obligations
- Not including a right of usufruct in a gift agreement
- Making a decision under pressure from family members
Every situation is unique, which is why it is advisable to consult a lawyer before making a decision.
Why is legal advice important before making a decision?
In practice, we often encounter situations where contracts were concluded without detailed legal consultation, which later leads to problems:
- Unclear obligations
- Insufficient protection of the right of usufruct
- Unexpected tax consequences
- Disputes among heirs
Every family situation is different and requires an individual approach.
Gift or Lifetime Care Agreement?
The decision between a gift agreement and a lifetime care agreement is not only a legal matter—it is also a matter of security, trust, and long-term protection.
If there is complete trust and no need for a formal obligation of care, a gift may be a sufficient solution.
However, if the priority is security, legal protection, and a guaranteed obligation of care, a lifetime care agreement is the better and safer option.
The most important thing is that the decision is made carefully and with professional guidance.
If you are considering concluding a gift agreement or a lifetime care agreement, it is advisable to seek professional advice before making a decision.
Law Office Marinela Ljubić Todoran provides detailed consultations, analyzes your specific situation, and proposes the legally safest solution.
Back to Blog